The Importance of Trust and Honesty in Leadership

It seems fitting to write a post about trust and honesty in leadership, especially as we are in the midst of the election cycle in the U.S., and we are bombarded with commercials and other material about the candidates for office in each state and nationally. In libraries and academic institutions, among the things we do is try to help our community members combat mis- and disinformation.  In doing so, we hope to help them understand who is - or who is not telling the truth and who can be trusted. Trust and honesty, of course, apply not only to our elected officials; it applies to us all and certainly to those who are in leadership positions. These characteristics are the cornerstones of any successful leadership. When leaders embody these qualities, they create a culture of openness, transparency, and mutual respect. Without them, an organization will likely falter as employees become disillusioned, disengaged, and distrustful of its mission. 

Why Trust is Essential in Leadership

Trust is the foundation upon which all relationships—personal and professional—are built. In a leadership context, trust involves the confidence that employees place in their leader's decisions, actions, and words. When employees trust their leader, they are more likely to be engaged, motivated, and aligned with the organization’s goals. 

Leaders who build trust foster a culture where employees feel comfortable voicing their concerns, sharing ideas, and taking risks. This openness can lead to innovation, improved problem-solving, and a more cohesive team environment. Trust between a leader and their team also contributes to higher morale, lower turnover rates, and increased productivity. 

How Honesty Amplifies Trust

Honesty Is inextricably linked to trust and is the vehicle through which trust is maintained. When leaders are honest, they demonstrate integrity and authenticity. This means being transparent not only about successes but also about failures or challenges the organization faces. Leaders who are forthright with their teams foster a sense of psychological safety, where employees feel that they can also be honest and vulnerable.

Honesty also involves consistency—leaders must walk the talk. Promising openness but failing to provide it can erode trust more quickly than never making the promise in the first place. Employees want to follow leaders who not only talk about ethical standards but also embody those values in their actions and decision-making processes.

The Consequences of Dishonesty in Leadership

When leaders are dishonest, the effects on their teams can be devastating and long-lasting.  Employees quickly lose faith (trust) in a leader who is caught lying or withholding critical information. This breakdown in trust can manifest in several harmful ways:

1. Decreased Morale and Engagement: When employees feel they can’t trust their leader, their morale declines. They may become disengaged, only doing the bare minimum to get by rather than putting in the extra effort that comes from feeling connected to a greater mission.
2. Increased Turnover: Distrust often leads to increased turnover. Employees who don’t trust their leaders are more likely to leave the organization, seeking environments where transparency and integrity are prioritized. High turnover can impact team dynamics, lead to a loss of institutional knowledge, and incur significant costs for hiring and training new employees.
3. Reduced Collaboration and Innovation: Dishonest leadership stifles collaboration and creativity. Employees are less likely to take risks or propose new ideas if they feel their leader is not being open with them. Without trust, teams are less willing to work together, fearing that their contributions may be undervalued or misrepresented by leadership.
4. Toxic Work Culture: Over time, dishonesty at the leadership level can create a toxic work culture. When employees see leaders getting away with dishonesty, it may embolden others to act unethically, leading to an unhealthy work environment
5. Loss of Credibility: Perhaps most importantly, dishonest leaders lose their credibility. Once lost, credibility is difficult, if not impossible, to regain. Employees may continue to work under a dishonest leader, but they will do so with skepticism and cynicism, which ultimately undermines the organization's success.

How Leaders Can Foster Trust and Honesty

There is no quick fix for building a foundation of trust and honesty, but there are several strategies leaders can use to create a transparent and trustworthy environment:

• Communicate Clearly and Often: Regular, open communication is critical to building trust. Leaders should keep their teams informed about both the good and the bad. Transparency breeds trust, and employees will appreciate knowing the full picture.
• Own Your Mistakes: No leader is perfect, and employees know this. They want to see a leader who admits mistakes and learns from them. Admitting when you’ve been wrong and taking steps to correct your mistakes shows integrity and humility.
• Be Consistent: Consistency in words and actions is crucial for maintaining trust. If you say you will do something, follow through. If circumstances change and you can’t communicate the reasons why.
• Encourage Feedback and Dialogue: Create an environment where employees feel safe offering feedback, even if it’s critical. Being open to input from your team shows that you value their perspectives and are committed to improvement.
• Lead by Example: Ultimately, the best way to inspire trust and honesty in others is to lead by example. Model the behavior you want to see in your team. If you demonstrate honesty, integrity, and transparency in your leadership, your team will likely follow suit.

Conclusion

Trust and honesty are indispensable for effective leadership. Leaders who prioritize these values build stronger, more cohesive teams capable of innovation and success. On the other hand, dishonesty can quickly erode trust, leading to low morale, high turnover, and a toxic work culture. By fostering a culture of transparency, consistency, and open communication, leaders can create an environment where trust thrives, and both individuals and the organization as a whole can succeed.

If you want to learn more about Inclusive Knowledge Solutions (IKS) and our approach to building healthier workplace cultures, please join our newsletter for insights and updates: https://gbc.ck.page/223a278bd7.

Below are some recommended readings that include sections on trust and honesty. 

Brown, B. (2018). *Dare to lead: Brave work. Tough conversations. Whole hearts.* Random House.

Covey, S. M. R. (2006). *The speed of trust: The one thing that changes everything*. Free Press.

Scott, K. (2017). *Radical candor: Be a kick-ass boss without losing your humanity*. St. Martin’s Press.

Sinek, S. (2014). *Leaders eat last: Why some teams pull together and others don't*. Portfolio/Penguin.