Being Heard vs. Being Listened To: Why the Difference Matters for Employee Engagement

This difference between being heard and being listened to can shape our overall workplace experience. Being truly listened to fosters a sense of respect and engagement, while merely being heard can leave us feeling overlooked or undervalued. It’s a distinction that, as employees, affects our motivation, our connection to the organization, and our willingness to contribute.

Being Heard vs. Being Listened To: Why the Difference Matters for Employee Engagement (And How to Address It)

Communication is critical. But as employees, there’s a significant difference between being heard and being listened to. The subtle yet important distinction often determines whether we feel valued, understood, and engaged at work. When we’re heard, our words may be acknowledged, but without true consideration or action. When we’re listened to, our ideas and concerns are thoughtfully absorbed, responded to, and lead to meaningful change.

In academic libraries and other workplaces, this distinction can directly impact morale, collaboration, and overall effectiveness. So, how do we move from merely being heard to truly being listened to? And how can leaders ensure they are creating an environment where listening is the norm?

What Does it Mean to Be Heard?

Being heard in the workplace means that your words are acknowledged, but not necessarily engaged with. You may share an idea, raise a concern, or ask a question, and receive a polite nod or acknowledgment. However, your input doesn’t lead to further dialogue, reflection, or actionable change.

This can feel frustrating as it often leaves you wondering whether your contributions were valued. In environments where being heard is the default, employees may feel like they’re simply going through the motions, without having an impact on the organization.

What Does it Mean to Be Listened To?

Being listened to, on the other hand, involves active engagement. When you're listened to, your ideas, concerns, and contributions are considered deeply, and you are given the opportunity to explain or clarify your perspective. Moreover, being listened to means that your input influences decisions or leads to a thoughtful response, even if it's not immediately acted upon.

In environments where listening is prioritized, employees feel valued and respected, and they are more likely to trust leadership and feel engaged in their work. True listening fosters a culture of collaboration, innovation, and continuous improvement.

Why the Difference Matters

The difference between being heard and being listened to directly impacts employee engagement. When employees are only heard, they can feel undervalued, which can lead to disengagement and frustration. Over time, this can create a workplace culture where staff hesitate to contribute or share new ideas because they believe their voices don’t matter.

On the other hand, when employees are truly listened to, they feel respected and empowered. This can lead to increased job satisfaction, greater collaboration, and more innovative ideas being brought to the table.

Solutions: Moving from Hearing to Listening

If you’re feeling that you’re being heard but not listened to, or if you're a leader looking to foster a more engaged team, here are some solutions to move from hearing to active listening.

As an employee, it’s important to take charge of how you communicate, especially if you feel you’re only being heard and not listened to. Here are ways you can foster more active engagement from your colleagues or supervisors:

• Clarify Your Message: When you share an idea or concern, ensure that your message is clear and concise. Be specific about what you’re asking for or suggesting and why it’s important.
• Ask for Feedback: Don’t hesitate to follow up on your ideas or ask for feedback. Asking questions like, “How do you see this fitting into our current strategy?” or “Can we discuss next steps?” can help move the conversation forward.
• Provide Evidence or Examples: Sometimes, giving context or examples can help your message resonate. If your suggestion is based on research or a successful past initiative, share that information to strengthen your case.

As a leader, fostering a culture of listening can drastically improve employee engagement. Here’s how you can ensure that employees feel listened to, not just heard:

• Practice Active Listening: When employees share ideas or concerns, give them your full attention. Maintain eye contact, avoid interrupting, and ask clarifying questions. Demonstrating that you’re fully engaged sends a powerful message that their input is valued.
• Follow Up: One of the simplest ways to show that you’re truly listening is to follow up on discussions. Even if an idea or concern isn’t actionable right away, circle back with an update or explanation. This builds trust and shows that you take employee contributions seriously.
• Create Opportunities for Dialogue: Formalize regular opportunities for employees to share their thoughts, such as during team meetings, feedback sessions, or suggestion boxes. Make it clear that these platforms are intended for meaningful dialogue, not just for surface-level discussion.
• Act on Feedback: It’s important that feedback leads to action. When feasible, act on employee suggestions and recognize them for their contributions. If a suggestion can’t be implemented, explain why, and thank them for their input. Providing this level of transparency ensures employees know their voices are respected.

Whether you’re an employee or a leader, practicing empathy and emotional intelligence can strengthen your listening skills. Empathy allows you to connect with others on a deeper level, helping you understand their perspectives and motivations.

• Put Yourself in Their Shoes: When someone is speaking, try to understand where they’re coming from. How might their experiences influence their concerns or ideas?
• Ask Open-Ended Questions: Rather than assuming you understand someone’s point, ask open-ended questions like, “Can you tell me more about your thought process?” This invites a deeper conversation and shows you’re interested in truly understanding.
• Reflect and Validate: After someone shares their thoughts, reflect back what you’ve heard to confirm your understanding. For example, “What I’m hearing is that you feel this process could be more efficient. Is that right?” Validating their concerns reinforces that you’re not only hearing their words but taking them seriously.

Conclusion: The Power of Listening in the Workplace

The difference between being heard and being listened to is profound, and it can make or break the level of engagement, satisfaction, and trust employees feel. In academic libraries, and workplaces in general, ensuring that every voice is truly listened to requires proactive communication, empathetic leadership, and a commitment to follow-through. When employees feel that their contributions are valued, the entire organization benefits from greater collaboration, innovation, and a more positive work environment.

By actively listening rather than just hearing, we can create workplaces where everyone feels respected, empowered, and engaged.

Interested in learning more about how on being heard versus being listened to? Sign up for our Inclusive Knowledge Solutions newsletter to receive tips, tools, and strategies for navigating change and building strong, successful library teams.